This post on gifts for Islanders fans contains affiliate links, which means that if you make a purchase through a link on this page, I receive a small kickback at no extra cost to you.

So, you’re looking for an awesome gift for the New York Islanders fan in your life. This is the perfect post for you!

In this post, I’m sharing 22 super cool gift ideas any Islanders fan will love, and that’s coming from a huge Isles fan myself.

There is truly something for everyone in this gift guide no matter how they show their Islanders pride - apparel, decor, collecting memorabilia, or even playing hockey themselves.

I’ve compiled a list with a ton of variety on it, where you’ll find some great gift recommendations for fans of all ages and genders.

I hope you find exactly what you’re looking for on this list or that it gives you some great inspiration on what to get for your Islanders fan.

If you love any of the ideas in this list, remember that you can always save them directly to Pinterest by clicking or tapping the red “save” button in the upper left corner of each image.

Gifts For New York Islanders Fans

#1: Islanders Leather Wallet

The first gift idea I have for you is this beautiful leather Islanders wallet.

Everyone needs some sort of wallet or to-go bag!

It’s one of those life essentials that makes for a perfect gift because your giftee will get use out of it for years to come.

This wallet has a beautiful design that’s simple enough to appeal to a wide range of fans, but it’s an ideal pick for dads, uncles, brothers, grandpas, and so forth.

#2: Officially Licensed Puck

Here’s a classic gift idea all fans will love. Whether you’re buying for an 18 year old girl or a 50 year old guy, every Islanders fan needs a puck!

These look great displayed on a desk, nightstand, dresser, shelf, or by using my next gift recommendation.

#3: Hockey Puck Holder

How cool is this wood hockey puck holder? If your giftee is someone who collects pucks, this is a no brainer.

This will look awesome hanging up in a den or man cave and will make any already impressive puck collection look even more so.

Plus, it’s hand painted, and beautifully done so at that!

#4: Insulated Coffee Tumbler

Tumblers are another gift idea that works for almost anyone:

Particularly fans who are always on the go like college students or adults who love making their morning coffee and drinking it on their way to work.

You can even put together a gift set and give a tumbler in combination with their favorite pack of tea or coffee, and a reusable straw or stirring spoon.

#5: Tie Dye Crewneck

How awesome is this hand tie dyed Islanders crewneck? I think this is something any fan would love!

If your fan is a fashion enthusiast who loves wearing cool colors and patterns, this gift will be right up their alley.

#6: Islanders License Plate Frame

Always believe - drive for five, baby. For the Islanders fan that also loves their car, why not give them a gift that combines two things they’re passionate about?

This is a super cool gift idea to add a fun level of personalization to any fan’s car.

You can even pair it with other car accessories like stickers, steering wheel decals, and mirror hangings.

#7: Iconic Islanders Plays Coaster Set

This has got to be one of my absolute favorite recommendations on this list.

I think these coasters are one of the most beautiful and unique gift ideas for sports fans I’ve ever seen (this shop has versions for other sports teams too if you want to check those out).

It’s fairly self explanatory, but in case you’re not a fan and you’re looking for a gift for someone who is, these coasters illustrate some of the most iconic plays in all of Islanders history, including the overtime Stanley Cup winning goal in 1980.

This goal marked the birth of a dynasty and the first Stanley Cup in Islanders history - the first of four straight.

Fans who are old enough to remember (and even ones who aren’t like me) all of these incredible moments will love the detail on these and enjoy reminiscing on some of their favorite memories as an Isles fan.

#8: Nassau Coliseum Panoramic Poster

This next gift idea is also one that celebrates a major moment in Islanders history, this one much more recent: the final regular season game at Nassau Coliseum, home of the aforementioned dynasty.

The Islanders closed out their final regular season game at the Coliseum, which many fans have described as a second home, with a 5-1 win over the New Jersey Devils in 2021.

This gorgeous panoramic poster capturing that final victory makes a meaningful gift for long time fans who followed the team’s ups and downs throughout their time at the Coliseum.

#9: Islanders Throw Blanket

The Islanders now play at beautiful UBS Arena, and if you’re watching games from the comfort of your couch at home, you need a comfy blanket like this one!

I love the bold design on this throw and this is another awesome gift idea that will work for kids and adults alike.

#10: New York Hockey Crewneck

Next, I’ve got another stylish crewneck sweatshirt that’s perfect for young female fans, but honestly has a pretty unisex design that all fans can enjoy!

#11: Vintage Style Islanders Cap

If your giftee is a frequent hat wearer, this next gift idea is definitely worth checking out.

This is a really cool vintage style cap with a beautiful Islanders patch on the front and a soft mesh back.

I love the retro style script the patch uses and gorgeous color combo of soft blue, white, and orange.

Plus, the patch features more of an off white than a classic white, giving it a super pretty faded, vintage look.

This cap is perfect to wear to Islanders games! You can easily make a gift set using this and one of the crewnecks I mentioned earlier, too.

#12: “Ew, Rangers” T-Shirt

Now, a gift that takes a more humorous approach. It’s no secret that Islanders and Rangers fans don’t exactly get along.

If your giftee happens to be a Rangers hater, a gift like this will definitely give them a good chuckle.

#13: Stanley Cup Trophy Replica

The Stanley Cup.

We all want it, and yet only one lucky team each year gets to hoist it in the air and bask in the glory as that year’s champions.

This next gift idea is a pretty cool one - a Stanley Cup replica highlighting all four Isles championships.

This isn’t a full size replica, but I think this would look great on display with any fan’s collection of pucks, hockey cards, jerseys, posters, figurines, and other memorabilia.

#14: 4x Stanley Cup Champions Banner

Here’s another great decor piece to celebrate the Islanders dynasty!

This flag will look sharp hanging outside your house or in a front yard.

It’ll look great indoors too, and it’s perfect to have on display when the Isles are in the playoffs for good luck.

#15: Islanders Beer Bottle Opener

Next, a super cool gift idea for fans over 21.

If your giftee is the kind of hockey fan that loves to sit back and enjoy their favorite bottled alcohol during games, get them this Islanders themed beer bottle opener.

It’s made to look like a hockey puck, too, which just makes it that much more awesome. Any fan will definitely get a kick out of it!

#16: Beer Koozies

If you’re looking for the ideal gift to pair with the beer bottle opener I just mentioned, look no further than these Isles themed beer koozies.

Together, those make a perfect gift set that’s sure to enhance any fan’s game watching experience!

#17: Handmade Islanders Scrunchie

Here’s kind of a unique gift idea but one that I definitely want to mention.

These are handmade Islanders scrunchies from Etsy and make a great gift for girls and women of any age (or for guys if they have really long hair and happen to like wearing scrunchies).

You can gift these in a set of multiple or with another piece of apparel like a sweatshirt, t-shirt, or jersey!

#18: Isles Legends Framed Wall Hanging

Next is something I think would look perfect in a den or hockey fan cave next to other Isles posters, flags, and wall hangings.

This is a framed tribute to some of the greatest Islanders legends of all time that spearheaded the team to four straight Stanley Cups in the 80s.

I love anything that celebrates the team’s history, and if your giftee does too, this is an awesome gift you should definitely consider getting them.

#19: Small Street Hockey Kit

Is your giftee a kid who loves playing hockey, either on an ice rink or classic street hockey?

They’ll adore this Islanders themed street hockey set that comes with a mini net, mini sticks, and a street hockey puck.

This is something they’ll have a ton of fun with, indoors or outdoors, with others or on their own.

For double the fun, get them two sets so they’ll have two nets, four sticks, and two pucks to play with friends and family.

#20: Kids’ Street Hockey Goalie Mask

If they’re into street hockey, this youth goalie mask makes an awesome gift that they’ll love wearing and will also help keep them safe while playing.

#21: New York Islanders Slippers

Everyone needs a comfy set of house slippers to chill out in. Why not get a hockey themed pair?

These are perfect to watch games in, and pair great with a blanket or cozy pair of PJs for a gift set.

#22: Islanders Metal Street Sign

Finally, I’ve got one more decor find for your hockey fan cave.

These street signs are a classic, and if your giftee doesn’t already have one, they’ll love adding this to their wall.

I’ve always loved how sharp the Islanders’ branding is, and this sign is no exception.

It features a bold blue, orange, and silver color combo and a beautiful shiny finish that’ll ensure it looks awesome wherever it’s hung.

Outro & Closing Thoughts

That wraps up my list of gifts for Islanders fans!

These are some seriously cool finds that I’m so glad I was able to share with you today.

I hope one or more of these caught your eye and makes a fellow Isles fan’s day!

A bonus gift idea is to actually get them tickets to a game if that’s something you’re able to do.

I’ll never forget my first Islanders game at UBS Arena.

Watching a game in person for the first time, getting to do the iconic “yes yes yes” chant with thousands of other fans, and celebrating a 3-0 Isles victory is one of my favorite memories, and I truly can’t wait to go back.

But if not, you’ve got some awesome ideas right here that are bound to surprise and delight any fan.

Thanks for reading my post “22 Gifts For New York Islanders Fans! (That They'll LOVE).”

For handmade digital art prints, icon packs, wallpapers, & more designed by me, be sure to stop by my digital boutique: Designed By Nikki Lo.

Connect with me!

22 Gifts For New York Islanders Fans! (That They'll LOVE)